it is ironic, isn't it?

In the 8th grade world, we are exploring irony as a literary device. As I was trolling for material/examples in pop culture to add to our reading, I found some interesting commentary on Alanis Morissette's little ditty, Ironic. I always loved laughing at that song, because few of her vignettes are ironic in the least. Which is, ironically, quite ironical.

I wish I could take credit for the following thoughts, but they were written by one Matt Sturges back in 1996, when the song was red-hot. I thought it was funny, and as I will be sharing this Nineties throwback with my students (who may or may not appreciate it) I thought I would also share it with you:

Alanis Morissette has taken more than her share of hits for the song "Ironic." Critics have
argued that she doesn't really understand the meaning of the word, and that the examples of
irony she gives are simply not ironic. To be perfectly honest, I'm more surprised that there
are music critics who do know what "ironic" means than I am that there are 21 year-old pop
singers who don't. But that's a whole other essay.

It's not an easy word to define. Not even language scholars agree on whether a certain
situation is "ironic" or not. For instance, if Alanis and Moose (Alanis's childhood costar
cum nemesis) both moved independently to LA from Ontario and later became lovers, some
would argue that this situation by itself constitutes irony. On the other hand, if Alanis and
Moose each moved because they individually were convinced that Ontario was devoid of
potential mates, and then met each other at a bar in LA, that would be ironic.

So in the interest of fairness, and erring generously in her favor, I took the time to examine the lyrics of Alanis's song, and discover for myself what was truly ironic and what wasn't. Results are
tallied below:

1. "An old man turned ninety-eight/He won the lottery and died the next day."

While an amusing (if morbid) coincidence, there is nothing particulary ironic about
the death. It is certainly an awe-inspiring sequence of events -- the gentleman celebrating his
98th birthday, winning the lottery, and dying all in a two day period. What kind of
luck is that? The ineffective slant rhyme, btw, is a little jarring, too.

2. "It's a black fly in your Chardonnay."

The irony here is that there is nothing remotely ironic about this line. In perhaps her one sweet moment of unadulterated genius, Alanis has shown us the true meaning of irony by giving an example of it that isn't ironic at all! It's a deliberate contrast between apparent and intended meaning: the textbook definition of irony!

3. "It's a death row pardon two minutes too late."

This one's kind of a coin toss, and really depends on the context. Imagine the following situation: Jimmy is black and has allegedly murdered fifteen people in Texas, with malice aforethought. No doubt he's going to fry, right? All the while, his pretty young Public Defender facing obstacles both legal and societal, struggles to overturn Jimmy's conviction. The actual killer, as it happens, was the son of a cattle rancher whom Jimmy'd stripped of a football to make the winning play at the cattle rancher's son's homecoming game.

The pretty young Public Defender, after years of searching, finally discovers the blood-stained sand wedge the cattle rancher's son used in the murders, covered up and down with his incriminating fingerprints. The PYPD races to the aid of Jimmy, with whom she's fallen in love and doesn't care who knows, and receives a stay of execution for her wrongly-accused beloved.

But irony of ironies: the pretty young Public Defender forgot to set her clock forward for daylight savings time, and Jimmy's already been dead for two minutes while she's breathing a sigh of relief in the Governor's office as the Governor, bewildered, makes the phone call only to discover to everyone's dismay that Jimmy's already toast and now he has to break the news to the pretty young Public Defender, who isn't going to take this little zigzag of kismet well, one suspects. Now,
that's ironic. That was so easy, there's no way I'm giving Miss Thing credit for it.

4. "It's like rain on your wedding day."

Nope.

5. "It's a free ride when you've already paid."

Sorry, no. Alanis seems to think that "irony" means "bad timing".

6. "It's the good advice that you just didn't take."

This is very close! Ignoring good advice is ironic, but only if the listener suffers some kind of befitting karmic punishment as a result. Alanis gets half a point for the setup, but because she only sketchily implies the irony, we cannot grant her full credit.

7. "Mr. Play It Safe was afraid to fly/ He packed his suitcase and kissed his kids
good-bye/ He waited his whole damn life to take that flight/And as the plane
crashed down he thought, Well, isn't this nice?"

This quatrain is truly a feather in Alanis's cap, because it contains not one, but two legitimate instances of actual, honest to God irony. A) It is, indeed, ironic that someone who is afraid of flying would die in a plane crash during his first flight; it's an unexpected disruption in the normal course of events that gives us insight into human folly. And B) said someone is being, you guessed it, ironic when he says, "Well, isn't this nice?" since we must presume that he is being sarcastic.

8. "It's a traffic jam when you're already late."

See No. 5. When Alanis finds a concept she likes, she runs with it.

9. "A no-smoking sign on your cigarette break."

Oh, come on. You were doing so well with the plane guy.

10. "It's like ten thousands spoons when all you need is a knife."

If the speaker is rifling through a silverware drawer which is known to contain knives, then this is ironic. If she's in a spoon factory, it isn't.

11. "It's meeting the man of my dreams/ And then meeting his beautiful wife."

The implied irony here is that Alanis has searched high and low for her soulmate, finds him only
to discover that, wouldn't you know it?, he's married. All the good ones are taken,
aren't they? But a moment's consideration will show that the situation is actually in no way
ironic, since we would expect all the good ones to be taken. What would be ironic would
be to meet some ugly, stupid, fat kid that Alanis spurned while a cast member of
Nickelodeon's You Can't Do That on Television, and then meet his beautiful wife.

Final Tally

Attempts at describing irony: 11
Successful attempts: 2.5
Confusion of irony with "poor sense of timing": 6
Completely missing the term: 3

Here's to hoping 8th graders get a better grasp of the term than Alanis...